Relay Attack Risks and Prevention

Relay Attack Risks and Prevention

A relay attack is a type of cyber-attack that involves intercepting and manipulating the communication between two devices or systems aiming to deceive them into believing they are in close proximity to gain unauthorized access or control. This type of cyberattack is commonly associated with security vulnerabilities in authentication protocols, such as those used in keyless entry systems for cars or in contactless payment systems.

Relay Attack Risks and Prevention

Relay Attack Overview

Commonly used in the context of keyless entry systems, contactless payments, or garage door openers, a relay attack involves capturing signals from a legitimate device, such as a key fob or payment card, and relaying these signals to the target system, tricking it into granting unauthorized access. This manipulation of signals allows attackers to remotely unlock cars, make unauthorized payments, or open garage doors, emphasizing the importance of implementing robust security measures, such as encryption, secure authentication protocols, and technology designed to resist relay attacks.

In a relay attack, an attacker typically places themselves between the legitimate parties (e.g., a user and a system) and relays communication between them. The goal is to make it appear as though the attacker is the legitimate user to one party and the legitimate system to the other. This can be done using different techniques, such as intercepting and forwarding signals, messages, or authentication tokens.

For example, in the context of a keyless entry system for a car, an attacker might use a device to intercept the signals between the car and the key fob when the legitimate user tries to unlock the car. The attacker then relays these intercepted signals to unlock the car, making it appear as if the attacker has the legitimate key fob.

To defend against relay attacks, security measures such as secure authentication protocols, encryption, and secure key exchange mechanisms are essential. For instance, using time-sensitive codes or cryptographic tokens that change with each authentication attempt can help prevent attackers from successfully relaying communication between the parties.

Relay Attack Statistics

Specific payment and car relay attack statistics can be challenging to obtain due to various factors. The prevalence of relay attacks on contactless payment cards or keyless entry systems can vary, and many incidents may go unreported or undetected.

However, contactless payment systems and keyless entry systems have been subjects of security research, and vulnerabilities in these systems have been demonstrated by security experts. Researchers have shown that it is possible to perform relay attacks on contactless payment cards and keyless entry systems under certain conditions.

For example, in 2018, researchers at the University of Birmingham in the UK demonstrated a relay attack on keyless entry systems for cars. They were able to intercept and relay signals between the car and the key fob, effectively allowing them to unlock and start the car without physical access to the key.

Similarly, researchers have demonstrated relay attacks on contactless payment cards, where attackers can intercept the communication between the card and the card reader to make unauthorized transactions.

It’s important to note that the industry continually works to address security vulnerabilities, and updates to protocols and systems may have been implemented to mitigate the risk of relay attacks. Users can also take steps to enhance their security, such as using card sleeves designed to block RFID signals or being aware of their surroundings to prevent close-range attacks.

In a report by Tracker, a UK based car tracking company, it was reported that “80% of all stolen and recovered cars in 2017 were stolen without using the car keys.”. It is estimated that the car security market will be worth $10 billion between 2018 and 2023.

How Relay Attack Works in Car Theft

In the context of car theft, a relay attack involves intercepting and relaying the signals between a car’s key fob and the vehicle itself. Keyless entry systems in cars often use a technology called radio frequency identification (RFID) or similar wireless communication methods. Here’s a general overview of how a relay attack on a car’s keyless entry system might work:

Identification of Target: The attacker identifies a target vehicle equipped with a keyless entry system. They observe the owner using the key fob to lock or unlock the car.

Equipment Setup: The attacker uses specialized equipment, such as a relay device, to intercept the communication between the car and the key fob.

Signal Interception: The relay attack typically involves two main components: one near the car and one near the key fob. The first component intercepts the signals from the car to the key fob, and the second component intercepts the signals from the key fob to the car. These components work together to extend the effective range of the key fob.

Signal Relay: The intercepted signals are relayed between the two components, effectively creating a bridge or “relay” between the car and the key fob.

Unlocking the Car: The car’s keyless entry system, tricked by the relayed signals, interprets them as if the legitimate key fob is in close proximity. As a result, the car unlocks, allowing the attacker to gain access.

Starting the Engine: In some cases, after gaining access to the car, the attacker may use additional techniques to start the car’s engine, completing the theft.

It’s important to note that this type of attack is most effective against vehicles with keyless entry systems that lack adequate security measures to prevent relay attacks. As a countermeasure, some car manufacturers have implemented features like secure keyless entry systems that use cryptographic methods, time-sensitive codes, or distance-based authentication to mitigate the risk of relay attacks.

To protect against relay attacks, car owners can consider using additional security measures, such as keeping their key fob in a signal-blocking pouch when not in use or opting for aftermarket security devices that provide additional layers of protection.

Managing Relay Attacks in Car Theft

Mitigating relay attacks in car theft involves implementing security measures to protect keyless entry systems from unauthorized access. Here are some strategies to help mitigate the risk of relay attacks:

Use a Faraday Cage or Signal-Blocking Pouch: Store your car key fob in a Faraday cage or a signal-blocking pouch when not in use. These devices block electromagnetic signals and prevent the key fob from emitting signals that could be intercepted by attackers.

Keyless Entry System Design: Car manufacturers should design keyless entry systems with robust security features. This may include the implementation of cryptographic protocols, time-sensitive codes, and distance-based authentication to prevent relay attacks.

Distance-Based Authentication: Implement systems that use distance-based authentication. If the key fob is not within a certain proximity to the car, the system should not allow the car to be unlocked or started.

Secure Keyless Entry Protocols: Use secure keyless entry protocols that incorporate strong encryption and authentication mechanisms. Regularly update and patch the software to address potential vulnerabilities.

Motion Sensors: Integrate motion sensors into the keyless entry system. These sensors can detect if the key fob is stationary or being moved, helping to differentiate between a legitimate user and an attacker attempting a relay attack.

Aftermarket Security Devices: Consider using aftermarket security devices designed to protect against relay attacks. These devices may include signal jammers, relay attack detectors, or additional authentication mechanisms.

Manual Disabling of Keyless Entry: Some vehicles allow users to manually disable the keyless entry system when it’s not needed, such as when parked at home. Check your car’s manual to see if this is an option.

Security Awareness: Educate car owners about the risks of relay attacks and the importance of safeguarding their key fobs. Promote good security practices, such as using signal-blocking pouches and being vigilant about the security of their keyless entry systems.

Security Audits and Testing: Car manufacturers and security professionals should conduct regular security audits and testing to identify and address potential vulnerabilities in keyless entry systems.

Regulatory Standards: Encourage the development and adoption of industry-wide security standards for keyless entry systems in vehicles. Compliance with robust security standards can contribute to better overall security.

It’s important to note that the effectiveness of these measures can vary, and ongoing research and development are crucial to staying ahead of evolving security threats. Car owners should stay informed about security recommendations from manufacturers and security experts and be proactive in implementing security measures to protect against relay attacks.

How Relay Attack Works in Payment Fraud

In the context of payment fraud, a relay attack typically targets contactless payment cards or mobile payment systems that use Near Field Communication (NFC) technology. Here’s a general overview of how a relay attack on a contactless payment system might work:

Identification of Target: The attacker identifies a target individual with a contactless payment card or mobile device capable of making contactless payments.

Equipment Setup: The attacker uses specialized equipment, such as an NFC reader and a relay device, to intercept the communication between the contactless card or mobile device and the payment terminal.

Signal Interception: The relay attack involves two main components: one near the payment terminal and one near the victim’s contactless card or mobile device. The first component intercepts the signals from the payment terminal, and the second component intercepts the signals from the contactless card or mobile device.

Signal Relay: The intercepted signals are relayed between the two components, effectively creating a bridge or “relay” between the payment terminal and the contactless card or mobile device.

Unauthorized Transaction: The payment terminal, tricked by the relayed signals, processes the transaction as if the legitimate card or device is in close proximity. This can lead to an unauthorized payment being made, and the attacker may be able to make purchases or transactions on behalf of the victim.

Relay attacks on contactless payment systems exploit the fact that these systems are designed for convenience and quick transactions. The attackers take advantage of the short-range communication between the payment card or device and the terminal.

Managing Payment System Relay Attack

To mitigate the risk of relay attacks in payment systems, some security measures include:

Transaction Limits: Implementing limits on the amount that can be spent in a single contactless transaction.

Authentication Mechanisms: Using additional authentication methods, such as requiring a PIN for certain transactions or implementing biometric authentication on mobile devices.

Secure Elements: Employing secure elements or secure chips in payment cards and devices to store sensitive information and prevent unauthorized access.

Tokenization: Using tokenization to replace card data with tokens for each transaction, minimizing the risk of intercepted data being misused.

As with any security threat, the financial industry continually works to enhance security measures and address emerging vulnerabilities. Users are also encouraged to stay informed about security best practices and to promptly report any suspicious activity on their accounts.

Relay Attacks and Garage Doors

Garage door openers, while providing convenience for homeowners, also pose certain security risks that need attention. One significant risk is the potential vulnerability to remote attacks, particularly relay attacks. In a relay attack scenario, attackers intercept and relay signals between the garage door opener and its remote control, tricking the system into thinking that the legitimate remote is in close proximity. This unauthorized access could lead to burglaries or break-ins if exploited by malicious individuals.

One common vulnerability in traditional garage door openers is the use of fixed or easily cloned codes for remote control communication. Older systems might lack advanced security features like rolling codes or frequency hopping, making them susceptible to interception and replay attacks. Additionally, if users store their garage door opener remotes in easily accessible locations, such as within vehicles parked outside, it increases the risk of unauthorized access.

Modern garage door openers often come equipped with improved security features, including rolling code technology, which changes the code with each use, making it more challenging for attackers to replicate signals. However, users must stay vigilant, regularly update their garage door opener’s firmware, and adopt security best practices such as securing remote controls in signal-blocking pouches when not in use.

To enhance garage door security comprehensively, homeowners can also consider physical security measures like reinforcing entry points and installing additional locks. A combination of technological safeguards, user awareness, and proactive security practices is crucial to mitigating the risks associated with garage door openers.

Relay Attack Summary

Relay attacks pose significant security risks across various technologies, from car keyless entry systems to contactless payment methods and garage door openers. In a relay attack, malicious actors intercept and relay signals between a legitimate device (such as a key fob, payment card, or remote control) and its target system, tricking the system into granting unauthorized access.

In the context of car theft, relay attacks can compromise keyless entry systems, allowing attackers to unlock and even start a vehicle without possessing the actual key fob. This underscores the need for robust security measures in keyless entry protocols, such as implementing cryptographic methods, time-sensitive codes, and distance-based authentication to prevent relay attacks.

Similarly, contactless payment systems are vulnerable to relay attacks, where attackers intercept and relay signals between a device and a payment portal. This could lead to unauthorized transactions, emphasizing the importance of secure authentication protocols, transaction limits, and tokenization to protect against relay attacks in the financial sector.

Garage door openers, which increasingly rely on wireless communication, are also susceptible to relay attacks. Without adequate security controls, attackers could exploit vulnerabilities in fixed or easily cloned codes, gaining unauthorized access to garages. Mitigating this risk involves adopting advanced security features like rolling code technology and educating users about secure practices, such as storing remote controls in signal-blocking pouches.

To counteract relay attacks comprehensively, it’s essential for manufacturers to design systems with robust security features, for users to stay informed about potential threats and adopt secure practices, and for both parties to collaborate in implementing technological advancements that address emerging vulnerabilities. Regular updates, secure authentication mechanisms, and a combination of physical and digital security measures are crucial components of an effective defense against relay attacks.

Identity and access management certifications